Seasons Real World/Road Rules Challenge Challenge 2000 Extreme Challenge Battle of the Seasons (2002) The Gauntlet The Inferno Road Rules: All Stars Battle of the Sexes Battle of the Sexes 2 The Inferno II The Gauntlet 2 The Inferno 3 The Gauntlet III The Ruins Cutthroat Battle of the Seasons (2012) The Duel The Island The Duel II Free Agents Invasion of the Champions XXX: Dirty 30 Vendettas Fresh Meat Fresh Meat II Rivals Battle of the Exes Rivals II Battle of the Exes II Battle of the Bloodlines Rivals III Spring Break Challenge Champs vs. Pros Champs vs. Stars Cast Real World Johnny Devenanzio Chris Tamburello Aneesa Ferreira Wes Bergmann Paula Meronek Coral Smith Mike Mizanin Beth Stolarczyk Road Rules Derrick Kosinski Veronica Portillo Timmy Beggy Mark Long Katie Doyle Abram Boise Rachel Robinson Susie Meister The Challenge Diem Brown Evelyn Smith Jamie Banks Evan Starkman Vince Gliatta Laurel Stucky Kenny Santucci Camila Nakagawa Are You the One? Dario Medrano Tori Deal Christina LeBlanc Simone Kelly Nelson Thomas Devin Walker Hunter Barfield Amanda Garcia Recent blog posts Forum

Filter Posts Reset

Categories

Sort By

  • All
  • Following

Replacement Cast Members

Extreme Challenge
Ayanna Mackins replaced by Susie Meister
Susie replaced Ayanna after she was removed from the game for physically attacking Christian.

Battle of the Seasons (2002)
Lori Trespicio replaced by Coral Smith (pre-filming)
Lori was initially on the final cast as Mike M.'s partner but dropped after uncertainty of flying due to 9/11. Coral replaced her.

The Inferno
Dan Renzi replaced by Syrus Yarbrough (pre-filming)
Dan was initially on the final cast but dropped out due to appearance obligations. Syrus replaced him.
Piggy Thomas replaced by Christena Pyle
Piggy was initially on the final cast and flew out with her cast members but was sent home for unknown reasons. Christena replaced her and the first episode was re-filmed.

Battle of the Sexes 2
Beth Stolarczyk replaced by Cynthia Roberts (pre-filming)
Beth was initially on the final cast but dropped out and was replaced by Cynthia.
Jisela Delgado replaced by Kina Dean (pre-filming)
Jisela was initially on the final cast but dropped after refusing to appear on a challenge with Coral. Kina replaced her.
Patrick Maloney replaced by Shawn Sealy (pre-filming)
Patrick was initially on the final cast but dropped after viewing his Road Rules: X-Treme edit. Shawn replaced him.

The Inferno II
Coral Smith and Melissa Howard replaced by Beth Stolarczyk and Rachel Robinson (pre-filming)
Both Coral and Melissa were initially cast but dropped and were replaced by Beth and Rachel.

The Inferno 3
Chris Tamburello replaced by Derrick Kosinski
CT was initially on the final cast and flew out with his castmates but was sent home after punching Davis during the beginning of filming. Derrick replaced him.

The Gauntlet III
Jenn Grijalva/Svetlana Shusterman replaced by Janelle Casanave (pre-filming)
Jenn was initially on the final cast but dropped out last minute. Svetlana dropped out the day of departure by leaving at the airport. Janelle was one of the replacements.
Tyrie Ballard replaced by MJ Garrett
MJ replaced Tyrie on the Rookies team after Tyrie had to return home due to an emergency.

The Duel II
Dan Walsh replaced by Ryan Kehoe (pre-filming)
Dan was initially on the final cast but dropped out last minute and was replaced by Ryan.
Adam King and Chris Tamburello replaced by MJ Garrett and Nehemiah Clark
MJ and Nehemiah replaced Adam and CT after the two got into an ugly brawl during the first days of filming.

The Ruins
Cara Zavaleta replaced by Susie Meister (pre-filming)
Cara was initially on the final cast but dropped out last minute and was replaced by Susie.

Fresh Meat II
Jonna Mannion replaced by Evelyn Smith (pre-filming)
Jonna was originally part of the final cast but was unable to find her passport at the time of departure and was replaced by Evelyn.

Cutthroat
Bronne Bruzgo replaced by Dunbar Merrill (pre-filming)
Bronne was initially on the final cast but dropped the week before filming and was replaced by Dunbar.
Kenny Santucci replaced by Derrick Kosinski (pre-filming)
Kenny was initially on the final cast but dropped the day of departure and was replaced by Derrick.

Rivals
Katie Doyle replaced by Katelynn Cusanelli (pre-filming)
Katie was originally meant to be Sarah's rival for the season, however she had to drop out due to work and was replaced by Katelynn.
Adam Royer replaced by Michael Ross
Michael replaced Adam R. as Leroy's partner after Adam was disqualified for physically attacking Ty.

Battle of the Seasons (2012)
Ashli Robson, Dunbar Merrill, Isaac Stout, and KellyAnne Judd replaced by Brandon Nelson, Camila Nakagawa, Cara Maria Sorbello, and Eric Banks (pre-filming)
Ashli, Dunbar, Isaac, and KellyAnne initially flew out to Turkey with the rest of the cast to compete as Team Sydney, however they were sent home during early filming and replaced by Team Fresh Meat for unknown reasons.
Carley Johnson replaced by Cara Maria Sorbello (pre-filming)
Carley was originally meant to take Cara Maria's spot on Team Fresh Meat, hence why Cara's original jersey name was covered with tape.

Rivals II
Naomi Defensor replaced by Cara Maria Sorbello
Cara Maria replaced Naomi as Cooke's partner after Naomi had a family emergency back home.

Battle of the Exes II
Brandon Swift and Jasmine Reynaud and Trey Weatherholtz and Laura Waller replaced by Adam Kuhn and Brittany Baldi and John Jacobs and Simone Kelly (pre-filming)
Jasmine, Laura, Swift, and Trey were supposed to compete in place of Adam, Brittany, John, and Simone but were all replaced last minute when Jasmine dropped from the cast.
Nia Moore replaced by Theresa Gonzalez
Despite initially being eliminated from the game, Theresa was brought back into the competition as Leroy's partner after Nia was disqualified for sexually assaulting Jordan.

Battle of the Bloodlines
Laurel Stucky/Marie Roda replaced by Christina LeBlanc/Jenna Compono (pre-filming)
Laurel and Marie were originally on the final cast but dropped out last minute. They were replaced by Christina and Jenna.
Tony and Shane Raines replaced by Abram and Mike Boise
Abram and Mike were brought into the competition after Tony was medically removed for rupturing his spleen.

Rivals III
Leroy Garrett and Averey Tressler replaced by Nelson Thomas and Amanda Garcia
Nelson and Amanda were brought into the competition after Leroy was medically removed for issues with his back/spine.
Brandon Tindel and Briana LaCuesta replaced by Devin Walker and Cheyenne Floyd
Despite having previously been eliminated, Devin and Cheyenne were brought back into the competition after Brandon quit because of homesickness.

XXX: Dirty 30
Alicia Wright replaced by Jenna Compono (pre-filming)
Alicia had to be hospitalized the night before departure due to health issues. She was replaced by Jenna.
Ashley Mitchell replaced by Briana LaCuesta
Briana was brought into the competition after Ashley quit due to lost luggage at the airport.
1 1