Evelyn Smith
Original Season Fresh Meat
Born February 13, 1987
Hometown Harrison, New York
Game Summary
Challenges Fresh Meat
The Inferno 3 (won)
The Gauntlet III (final)
The Island (won)
The Ruins
Fresh Meat II
Rivals (won)
Eliminations 7 (4 wins, 3 losses)
Money Won $167,000
Spin-offs Spring Break Challenge
Social Media


Fresh Meat

Bio: Ev is a tough-as-nails aspiring Olympian who is risking a college softball scholarship at the University of Arizona to compete in The Challenge. She is also risking a relationship: Her girlfriend fears Ev might cheat on her with a man given the opportunity. Sports, sex, determination and a cocky attitude? Ev was made for The Challenge.

Episode Challenge Partner Result
1 Stuck On Me Danny EXILE
2 Bush Whacked OUT

The Inferno 3

Bio: Ev was a tough-as-nails aspiring Olympian who risked a college softball scholarship at the University of Arizona to compete in the Fresh Meat Challenge. Sports, sex, determination and a cocky attitude? Seems like Ev was made for the Challenges. She was the top girl in the Fresh Meat trials, but unlucky for her Danny picked her as his teammate. With the Austin season on the chopping block, Ev and Danny were sent home before Ev even had a chance to show off her athletic prowess. Will The Inferno 3 be her second chance?

Episode Challenge Partners Result
1 Unbraided Bad Asses SAFE
2/3 Ladder Race SAFE
3 Battering Ram SAFE
4 Wrap and Roll SAFE
5 Rope Burn SAFE
6 Reversible Climbing Wall SAFE
7 Grape Smash SAFE
8 Steady As You Go SAFE
9 Leaps and Bounds SAFE
10 Dog Day Afternoon SAFE
11 Hand Car SAFE
12 Giraffic Park SAFE
13 Captain's Chair SAFE
14 Hook Me SAFE
15 Nothin' But Net WIN
16 The Big Five WINNER

Money Won: $40,000

The Gauntlet III

Bio: Regarded as the best female athlete of the lot, Ev returns to the Challenge as a feared competitor. She captured her first Challenge victory at The Inferno 3 and was not nominated for the Inferno once, a sign of the respect that opponents have for her. Her only weakness is her temper, and when the pressure is on, there's always a chance for a wild emotional freakout! Of course, everything is up for grabs if the athlete is distracted by love...

Episode Challenge Partners Result
1 Piñata Pit Veterans WIN
2 Screw You WIN
Roped In WIN
3 Wring Out WIN
Blind Man's Maze SAFE
4 Push It WIN
Man Overboard WIN
5 Assembly Required SAFE
Walk the Plank WIN
6 Pole Push WIN
I Dig You WIN
7 Over the Edge GAUNTLET
Mexican Blanket WIN
8/9 Chill Out SAFE
Well-Balanced SAFE
9 Army Strong LOSER

The Island

Bio: Still bitter and angry after her loss on The Gauntlet III, Evelyn comes into The Island with a determination to win like never before. With her mind always on the game, Evelyn tends to distance herself from the other players. As a result, she often comes up short in the social aspects of the competition. Will her physical attributes be enough to earn her a claim in the cash at stake?

Episode Face-Off Vote Result
1 Leaning Tower Tonya SAFE
2 Ring Wrestle Johnny SAFE
3 The Rack Robin SAFE
4 Ball Buster Ashli SAFE
5 Bridge It N/A WIN
6 Rat in a Cage Cohutta SAFE
7 Timber Colie SAFE
8 Water Bound N/A WIN
Final Challenge WINNER

Money Won: $75,000

The Ruins

Bio: Arguably the strongest woman to ever play the game, Evelyn is one fierce competitor. In her debut on Fresh Meat, Evelyn didn't last long, but made quite the impression. Evelyn returned to the Challenge and became a part of the winning team on The Inferno 3. We last saw Evelyn in Panama for The Island, where she found herself the target of constant ridicule from Johnny Bananas, and in a controversial move, she decided to team up with her enemies, leading them to a win. While Evelyn is a tough player, she can sometimes let her emotions eclipse her judgment. In the Ruins of Thailand, will Evelyn play with her heart or will she play with her head?

Episode Challenge Partners Result
1 Chain Gang Champions SAFE
2 Swing On By OUT

Fresh Meat II

Episode Challenge Partner Result
1 Dirty Mouth Luke SAFE
2 I'll Be There For You SAFE
3 Water Logged EXILE
4 King of the Wall SAFE
5 Drop Out SAFE
6 Turn Style SAFE
7 Airheads EXILE
8/9 Wrecking Ball OUT

Note: Evelyn served as a last-minute replacement for Jonna who could not participate due to a lost passport. She arrived after the draft and was automatically assigned as Luke's partner.


Bio: Evelyn is undeniably one of the most dominating players to ever don a Challenge jersey. Not one to back down, Evelyn asserts, "Unlike other girls in this game, I don't take a back seat." A fiercely independent competitor, Evelyn doesn't always play well with others and when asked about her playing style, she admits, "I don't really work well in partnerships and I'm hoping I don't have a partner this time around." Evelyn will have no such luck this season on Rivals, when she is attached to a partner with a less-than-stellar track record.

Episode Challenge Partner Result
1 High Dive Paula JUNGLE
2 Car Crusher WIN
3 Sync or Swim WIN
4 Hammock Crawl SAFE
5 Against the Current SAFE
6 Catch and Release SAFE
7 Sawed Off WIN
8/9 Bombs Away WIN
9/10 Final Challenge WINNER

Money Won: $52,000


Fresh Meat

Episode Exile Partner Opponents Result
2 Beach Course Danny Wes OUT

The Gauntlet III

Episode Gauntlet Opponent Result
7 Ball Brawl Casey WIN

The Ruins

Episode Ruins Opponent Result
2 Shadowfighter KellyAnne OUT

Fresh Meat II

Episode Exile Partner Opponents Result
3 Lost and Found Luke Paula WIN
7 Wes WIN
8/9 Weight For Me: Black Out Landon OUT


Episode Jungle Partner Opponents Result
1 Hands On Paula Aneesa WIN



  • Evelyn is currently tied with Veronica for female cast member with the most challenge wins.

Ad blocker interference detected!

Wikia is a free-to-use site that makes money from advertising. We have a modified experience for viewers using ad blockers

Wikia is not accessible if you’ve made further modifications. Remove the custom ad blocker rule(s) and the page will load as expected.