Jessica McCain
Original Season RW: Portland
Born January 26, 1991
Hometown Fayetteville, North Carolina
Game Summary
Challenges Rivals II
Free Agents
Battle of the Exes II
Rivals III
Eliminations 5 (1 win, 4 losses)
Social Media
Twitter MtvJess
Instagram chefjessmccain


Rivals II

Bio: Fresh off their stint on The Real World: Portland, Anastasia and Jessica may be far more at home at a makeup counter than they are on the playing field. Jessica quips, "Anastasia the athlete... said no one ever! Sports have never really been her thing from what I understand. But we're gonna change that." Jessica may be more physically capable than her willowy partner, but her perpetually sunny attitude rubs Anastasia the wrong way. Anastasia vents, "I can't believe I have to work with Miss Bubblegum Princess Sugar Walking on Cloud Nine girl. She is so annoying to me!" This team quickly makes waves when Anastasia hooks up with one of the game's most notorious troublemakers, infuriating another girl in the house. Will Anastasia's new romance win her a valuable ally? Or will this pair of princesses melt down in a hurry?

Episode Challenge Partner Result
1 Game of Inches Anastasia SAFE
2 XXX Games OUT

Free Agents

Bio: Good girl Jessica left Rivals II following her partner Anastasia’s epic meltdown. No longer held back by a teammate, Free Agents is Jessica’s chance to show what she’s made of. Jessica proclaims, “I don't think people see me as a threat this time because I didn't last very long in the previous Challenge. I have to play it cool and then just bam, hit them with it.” Although she claims she’s not looking for romance in the house, Jessica is all smiles when she makes an instant love connection. Don’t underestimate this former pageant queen—when it comes to performing in challenges, she just might shock everyone.

Episode Challenge Partner(s) Result
1 Out on a Ledge Team Black WIN
2 Auto Body Rally Leroy SAFE
3 Bar Crawl Team Brandon WIN
4 Bounce Out Team Red WIN
5 Piggy Back Team Purple WIN
6 Smarty Pants N/A SAFE
7 Sausage Party SAFE
8 Hold That Pose Team Devyn WIN
9 Dug Out Cara Maria OUT

Battle of the Exes II

Bio: When Dustin arrived on Free Agents newly single, it didn’t take long for his swag to win over Jessica’s Southern charm. However, lack of a political game sent Dustin packing early, and the budding romance was cut short. After their season, Jessica tried to pursue Dustin, but was dismayed to discover that Dustin had already moved on. Jessica explains, “I made plans to see Dustin, but found out he ended up having a girlfriend and he didn’t have the balls to tell me!” Dustin explains, “I didn't pursue a relationship with her like she thought we would and now my balls are in her hands.” Will Dustin and Jessica be able to recapture their once fun and flirty relationship to seize the win? Or will Jessica’s broken heart cause her to sabotage their chance of winning like Dustin sabotaged their chance at love?

Episode Challenge Partner Result
1 I Got You Babe Dustin OUT

Rivals III

Bio: Childish name-calling and screaming dominated Johnny and Jessica’s relationship on The Real World: Portland. In fact, Southern belle Jessica is still emotionally scarred from Johnny fat-shaming her repeatedly, revealing, “I was devastated. I don’t understand how you can fit that much dick into one personality.” Try as he might, Johnny just can’t come up with any compliments to describe his new partner, “Plain and simple, everything she does aggravates me. Her voice from across the room pierces my eardrums.” If Johnny had his way, he would never speak to Jessica again, but she sees friendship as necessary to their team success. Will the brutally honest Johnny be able to fake-play-nice and convince his partner that he respects her as a competitor? Or will this pair fall apart and resort back to the ugly name-calling of their past?

Episode Challenge Partner Result
1/2 Give Me Some Slack Johnny JUNGLE
3 Dirty Laundry SAFE
4/5 Out on a Limb OUT


Rivals II

Episode Jungle Partner Opponents Result
2 Hanging by a Thread Anastasia Cara Maria OUT

Free Agents

Episode Elimination Opponent Result
9 Balls In Cara Maria OUT

Battle of the Exes II

Episode Dome Partner Opponents Result
1 Pole Position Dustin Adam OUT

Rivals III

Episode Jungle Partner Opponents Result
2 Back It Up Johnny Devin WIN
5 Weight For Me Nelson OUT


Ad blocker interference detected!

Wikia is a free-to-use site that makes money from advertising. We have a modified experience for viewers using ad blockers

Wikia is not accessible if you’ve made further modifications. Remove the custom ad blocker rule(s) and the page will load as expected.