Male Contestants:
| Contestants | Original Season | Finished |
|---|---|---|
 |
Hunter Barfield AYTO? 3 |
WINNER |
 |
Leroy Garrett RW: Las Vegas 2011 |
Second Place |
 |
Darrell Taylor RR: Campus Crawl |
Third Place |
 |
Nelson Thomas AYTO? 3 |
Eliminated Episode 11 |
 |
Derrick Kosinski RR: Summer at Sea |
Eliminated Episode 11 |
 |
Jordan Wiseley RW: Portland |
Eliminated Episode 11 |
 |
Dustin Zito RW: Las Vegas 2011 |
Eliminated Episode 10 |
 |
Johnny "Bananas" Devenanzio RW: Key West |
Eliminated Episode 9 |
 |
Tony Raines RW: Skeletons |
Eliminated Episode 8 |
 |
Frank Sweeney RW: San Diego 2011 |
Eliminated Episode 7 |
 |
Zach Nichols RW: San Diego 2011 |
Eliminated Episode 6 |
 |
Vince Gilatta Battle of The Bloodlines |
Eliminated Episode 5 |
 |
Cory Wharton RW: Ex-Plosion |
Eliminated Episode 4 |
 |
Wes Bergmann RW: Austin |
Eliminated Episode 3 |
 |
Jamie Banks Battle of The Bloodlines |
Eliminated Episode 2 |
 |
Christopher "CT" Tamberuello RW: Paris |
Eliminated Episode 1 |
Female Contestants:
| Contestants | Original Season | Finished |
|---|---|---|
 |
Nia Moore RW: Portland |
WINNER |
 |
Tori Deal AYTO? 3 |
Second Place |
 |
Jenna Compono RW: Ex-Plosion |
Third Place |
 |
Ashley Mitchell RW: Ex-Plosion |
Eliminated Episode 11 |
 |
Laurel Stucky Fresh Meat II |
Eliminated Episode 11 |
 |
Nany Gonzalez Fresh Meat II |
Eliminated Episode 11 |
 |
Kailah Casillas RW: Go Big or Go Home |
Eliminated Episode 10 |
 |
Theresa Gonzalez |
Eliminated Episode 9 |
 |
Veronica Portillo RR: Summer at Sea |
Eliminated Episode 8 |
 |
Camila Nakagawa Spring Break Challenge |
Eliminated Episode 7 |
 |
Ashley Kelsey RW: San Diego 2011 |
Eliminated Episode 6 |
 |
Cara Marie Sorbello Fres Meat II |
Eliminated Episode 5 |
 |
KellyAnne Judd RW: Sydney |
Eliminated Episode 4 |
 |
Aneesa Ferreira RW: Chicago |
Eliminated Episode 3 |
 |
Emily Schromm RW: D.C |
Eliminated Episode 2 |
 |
Sarah Rice RW: Brooklyn |
Eliminated Episode 1 |
Teams
Red
| Contestants | |
|---|---|
| Ashley M | Eliminated |
| Camila | Eliminated |
| Cara Maria | Eliminated |
| CT | Eliminated |
| Cory | Eliminated |
| Derrick | |
| Frank | Eliminated |
| Jenna | |
| Bananas | |
| Jordan | |
| KellyAnne | |
| Nany | |
| Nelson | |
| Sarah | Eliminated |
| Theresa | |
| Vince |
Blue
| Contestants | |
|---|---|
|
Aneesa |
Eliminated |
|
Ashley K |
Eliminated |
| Darrell | |
| Dustin | |
| Emily | Eliminated |
| Hunter | |
| Jamie | Eliminated |
| Kailah | |
| Laurel | |
| Leroy | |
| Nia | |
| Tony | Eliminated |
| Tori | |
| Wes | Eliminated |
| Veronica | |
| Zach | Eliminated |
| Episode | Winners | Last Place | Gulag contestants (Voted) | Gulag game | Gulag outcome | |||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Gas Problems | Blue Team | N/A | Sarah | Cara Maria | Handcuffs | Cara Maria | Sarah | ||||
| CT | Vince | Vince | CT | |||||||||
| 2 | Football | Red Team | Laurel | Emily | Pole Wrestle | Laurel | Emily | |||||
| Jamie | Tony | Tony | Jamie | |||||||||
| 3 | Over The Hill | Red Team | Aneesa | Kailah | Back Up Off Me | Kailah | Aneesa | |||||
| Wes | Darrell | Darrell | Wes | |||||||||
| 4 | Maze Runner | Blue Team | KellyAnne | Jenna | Pole Me Over | Jenna | KellyAnne | |||||
| Derrick | Cory | Derrick | Cory | |||||||||
| 5 | Blue Team | Camila | Cara Maria | Wrecking Wall | Camila | Cara Maria | ||||||
| Derrick | Vince | Vince | Derrick | |||||||||
| 6 | Tangled | Red Team | Ashley K | Nia | Hall Brawl | Nia | Ashley K | |||||
| Tony | Zach | Tony | Zach | |||||||||
| 7 | Boue Team | Nany | Camila | Handcuffs | Nany | Camila | ||||||
| Nelson | Frank | Nelson | Frank | |||||||||
| 8 | Red Team | veronica | Kailah | Pole Wrestle | Kailah | Veronica | ||||||
| Darrell | Tony | Darrell | Tony | |||||||||
| 9 | Kailah, Nelson | Theresa, Jordan | Laurel | Bananas | Back Uo Off Me | Laurel | Theresa | |||||
| Jordan | Bananas | |||||||||||
| 10 | Trivia Crack | Nia, Vince | Kailah, Darrell | Tori | Dustin | Pole Me Over | Tori | Kailah | ||||
| 11 | Right to stay | Tori, Leroy, Nia, Darrell | Nany, Nelson | N/A | Breaking Out | Jenna | Ashley M | Laurel | ||||
| Hunter | Leroy | Vince | ||||||||||
| 12 | Finale | Nia, Hunter | 2nd;Tori and Leroy 3rd; Jenna and Darrell | |||||||||