Alternates are Jason H., Nia, Tyranny, Simone, Jamie B., Mitch
| Male Cast Member | Original Season | Finish | Female Cast Member | Original Season | Finish |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Andre Wilson | Real World: Atlanta | TBA | Anika Rashaun | Real World Seattle: Bad Blood | TBA |
| Anthony Cuomo | Battle of the Bloodlines | TBA | Ashley Mitchell | Real World: Ex-Plosion | TBA |
| Brad Fiorenza | The Real World: San Diego (2004) | TBA | Averey Tressler | The Real World: Portland | TBA |
| Cody Dunlap | Stranded With a Million Dollars | TBA | Ayiiia Elizarraràs | The Real World: Cancun | TBA |
| Cory Wharton | Real World: Ex-Plosion | TBA | Camila Nakagawa | Spring Break Challenge | TBA |
| Derrick Kosinski | Road Rules: X-Treme | TBA | CeeJai Jenkins | Real World: Go Big or Go Home | TBA |
| Eddie Williams | Are You the One?: Season 5 | TBA | Heather Cooke | The Real World: Las Vegas (2011) | TBA |
| Johnny Reilly | The Real World: Portland | TBA | Jenna Thomason | Real World: Go Big or Go Home | TBA |
| Juelz Rodriguez | Real World: Atlanta | TBA | Justice Malone | Real World: Atlanta | TBA |
| Marlon Williams | The Real World: Portland | TBA | Madison Walls | Real World: Skeletons | TBA |
| Nate Siebenmark | Are You the One?: Season 2 | TBA | Makani Paul | Stranded With a Million Dollars | TBA |
| Chris Ammon | Real World: Go Big or Go Home | TBA | Nany González | The Real World: Las Vegas (2011) | TBA |
| Shane Landrum | Road Rules: Campus Crawl | TBA | Santana Driver | Real World: Atlanta | TBA |
| Tony Raines | Real World: Skeletons | TBA | Violetta Milerman | Real World: Skeletons | TBA |